My Skeptical Sister
They look alike, they talk alike, they even live across the street from one another. But when it comes to the debate over the paranormal, these two sisters couldn’t be more opposite. Listen in, while one sister tries to convince the other that ghosts do, in fact, exist. They may never get to the bottom of the truth, but they’ll sure laugh a lot while trying.
Listen on:
Episodes
5 days ago
5 days ago
Out of all the life lessons the sisters will try to teach you, how to catch print may be the most useful.
Our fan favorite this week is Ashlee Bluett! If you're interested in getting your colors done, check out the studio, Color Theory in Bloomington, IN, www.discovercolortheory.com or IG and Facebook @discovercolortheory. Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Mar 23, 2026
Monday Mar 23, 2026
With all the personalities Erin goes through, she was bound to end up on witchy at least once…
Our fan favorite this week is Amy! Please consider supporting her favorite charity St.Judes. Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Mar 16, 2026
Monday Mar 16, 2026
One UFO in an episode is rare, two is unheard of!
Our fan favorite this week is Stacey! Please consider supporting your local YMCA. Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Mar 09, 2026
Monday Mar 09, 2026
The sisters never mind when Danny gets handsy
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Mar 02, 2026
Monday Mar 02, 2026
A man who leads with confidence AND takes care of the baby at night? Sign me up….living or not.
Our fan favorite this week is Rachel. Please support her cause of Donors Choose by going to www.donorschoose.org. Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Feb 23, 2026
Monday Feb 23, 2026
Join the sister for cunnilangus conversations
Our fan favorite this month is Birdie!! Please check out ways to support her new small business by going to linktr.ee/blackbirdrituals and blackbirdrituals.square.site/
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Feb 16, 2026
Monday Feb 16, 2026
Imagine waking up to find a humanoid praying mantis crouched in your bedroom — not a legend, not folklore, but a real-life college roommate!
Our fan favorite this month is Katie! She would like to spotlight the Immigrant Law Center of Minnesota who provides free representation for low income immigrants and refugees.
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Feb 09, 2026
Monday Feb 09, 2026
Tonight the girls get a little philosophical….
Our fan favorite this month is Trish! Be sure to follow her on all the socials by searching Trish the Medium! And if you want to try some of Hilary’s YUMMY biscotti, find her bakery, Twice Tempted on instagram @ladiesofthebite
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Feb 02, 2026
Monday Feb 02, 2026
Winter is coming…and the sisters are over it.
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz
Monday Jan 26, 2026
Monday Jan 26, 2026
Don't know how you do the voodoo that you do so well, it's a spell, hell, makes me wanna shoop, shoop, shoop.
Our fan favorite this month is Nicole! Be sure to support your local pet rescue and foster programs!
Please remember to Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify. If you would like to write in, find us on Patreon, buy MERCH, or find our social handles, go to our website, www.myskepticalsister.com You can also support us with a one time donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/myskepticaz