My Skeptical Sister

They look alike, they talk alike, they even live across the street from one another. But when it comes to the debate over the paranormal, these two sisters couldn’t be more opposite. Listen in, while one sister tries to convince the other that ghosts do, in fact, exist. They may never get to the bottom of the truth, but they’ll sure laugh a lot while trying.

Episodes

Jul 16, 2021

1hr 3 min

This week on My Skeptical Sister, the sisters read stories from fellow Oldham County ladies! Join in as they discuss the possibility of a psychic sighting, a mystery singer and the hereditary visitor-the hat man!
✨Thank you to our sponsor Zimmerman Art Glass. Visit their website at artzglass.com If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/ TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jul 9, 2021

52 min

A road trip all the way to Savannah, an expensive ghost hunt using a spirit box, EMF/EVP meter and even leaving her own children behind for a kid-free vacation...Erin will go to great lengths to try and prove that ghosts are real. Question is, will Meghann buy it, or will she need more proof? Listen to this week’s episode to find out if the believer finally convinces the skeptic!
If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jul 2, 2021

1hr 1 min

Our listeners from across the pond share their spooky stories that have the skeptics of all skeptics stumped! Could this be the week that the skeptic becomes the believer? If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/ TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jun 25, 2021

1hr 4 min

Join the sisters this week as they make their first live podcast debut at 3rd Turn Oldham Gardens!!! Thank you to all those who were able to come and all those who supported us from afar! Hopefully this is the first of many! Special thanks to Miranda, our fan favorite for hosting this incredible night! If you have an event that needs a spectacular venue and an event coordinator who will make your vision come to life, contact her at: 3rdturnbrewing.com If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jun 18, 2021

47 min

Join the sisters as they dive into a spooky story all the way from Malta, with a bonus side story about a UFO sighting! Also, a listener writes in a bone chilling story that leaves the sisters wondering what shadow figures are capable of!
If you would like to support our fan favorite’s cause this week, please check out the FG1 Foundation at https://www.foxg1research.org/foxg1syrdrome
If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/ TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jun 10, 2021

1hr 1 min

The sisters finally agree...this week’s episode has the scariest story to date! Join us while we laugh, gasp and get the pee scared out of us!
If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights!
Follow us on social media at:
* Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

28. BRO NIGHT

Jun 4, 2021

Jun 4, 2021

59 min

It’s Bro Night on MY Skeptical Sister this week as the sisters tackle two stories full of heavy metal, bulldozers and down right spooky vibes! Crack open a Yuengling or Rolling Rock in honor of Mare and join us for BRO NIGHT!
If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights!
Follow us on social media at:
* Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Jun 2, 2021

1hr 39 sec

The sisters have an unexplained guest, perhaps a festive ghost, who joins around the 2:43 mark and makes a strange whistling sound. This week’s episode includes stories of a spooky childhood bedroom, bazaar imaginary friends, and a visit from a loved one who’s passing leaves a bedroom aglow. PLUS, Erin finally tells her personal story that she has been click bating for weeks! Enjoy, and Happy New Year!

Jun 2, 2021

51 min

We can't agree about the paranormal, but we come together over our love for fish and chips...especially if they're free (hint, hint).  In this episode we hear stories from a local restaurant that has rumors of being haunted, and a house that used to be an old Civil War hospital!  

May 28, 2021

1hr 9 sec

Night terrors or demons? Possessed boom box or electricity doing what it does? DMT trip or visions of a future world savior? The sisters discuss these topics and more as they read fascinating listener stories this week!
If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights!
Follow us on social media at:
* Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  TikTok: @myskepticalsister_ *

Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125